Lucy Letby Case #13

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Because I had to learn a rule that English speakers don’t seem to know 😀
I don’t correct people though. Unless they’re my kids.
Congratulations you correctly learned a grammar rule that many people often get wrong? Not really a flex and I don’t really get the point you’re trying to make tbh.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Heart
Reactions: 6
But it isn't just multiples she's accused of harming, there's a lot of singletons too.
Just multiples are more common in a NICU setting as they are at higher risk for pre term delivery.
For context, there are 8 singletons and 4 sets of multiples she's either accused of murdering or attempting to murder.
Yes but I think this explains why she would target BOTH twins rather than just one. At least this is what I think. Was she jealous of those families? Loving parents? Maybe her own childhood was terrible?
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 8
I can't get my head round this either. Surely if she's innocent she'd say she was nosey or wanted to see how they were. Surely if she was guilty she'd have the sense to lie about being concerned for the family 🤷‍♀️
The only scenario that makes sense to me is that she was so distraught she couldn't think straight or was scared of getting in trouble at work by admitting to it.. which also doesn't seem like something a guilty person would care about.
My thoughts are that if she is guilty, she might not have been able to come up with a reason that sounded innocent, that doesn’t raise suspicion, so safer to just say you don’t remember doing it. If she’s guilty then her thoughts aren’t going to be like ours where an innocent explanation is obvious, surely?
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 9
I can't get my head round this either. Surely if she's innocent she'd say she was nosey or wanted to see how they were. Surely if she was guilty she'd have the sense to lie about being concerned for the family 🤷‍♀️
The only scenario that makes sense to me is that she was so distraught she couldn't think straight or was scared of getting in trouble at work by admitting to it.. which also doesn't seem like something a guilty person would care about.
Yeah it’s mad isn’t it. Hmm I don’t think there’s any sign she was distraught in these interviews. I also think if I was distraught I’d still have a better answer and be saying I know it was wrong to look them up but it didn’t mean anything etc. Her answers are very low key imo. I think she knows it’s not a good idea to try and tell detailed lies and that’s just an quick answer. She’s going down the lack of memory route a fair amount.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 7
But what are the odds of both of the twins suffering the same "collapse", as happened more than once?
I'd say there were slim, unless they both had exactly the same infection for example and they were both seriously struggling with prematurity and infection/condition

Yes but I think this explains why she would target BOTH twins rather than just one. At least this is what I think. Was she jealous of those families? Loving parents? Maybe her own childhood was terrible?
Possibly, I just think shes possibly quite sadistic, perhaps she even targeted multiples to see if there was a stronger twin/triplet as there usually is and perhaps then compared them to that of a singleton baby.
I don’t know, I just don't think she specifically targeted babies born in multiples. I think they were just easier access as they're the most common type of NICU paitent.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 7
I'd say there were slim, unless they both had exactly the same infection for example and they were both seriously struggling with prematurity and infection/condition


Possibly, I just think shes possibly quite sadistic, perhaps she even targeted multiples to see if there was a stronger twin/triplet as there usually is and perhaps then compared them to that of a singleton baby.
I don’t know, I just don't think she specifically targeted babies born in multiples I think they were just easier access as they're the most common type of NICU paitent.
Exactly 😢
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 4
But what are the odds of both of the twins suffering the same "collapse", as happened more than once?
I’ll do my weekly reminder 🤣 that with two sets of twins, it’s alleged one twin had insulin poisoning and the other twin had air emblous. What are the chances of that!

Yes but I think this explains why she would target BOTH twins rather than just one. At least this is what I think. Was she jealous of those families? Loving parents? Maybe her own childhood was terrible?
It’s possible she targeted both so it might look like they had the same mystery illness? Although that wouldn’t apply to the insulin/air embolus pairs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 14
I’ll do my weekly reminder 🤣 that with two sets of twins, it’s alleged one twin had insulin poisoning and the other twin had air emblous. What are the chances of that!



It’s possible she targeted both so it might look like they had the same mystery illness? Although that wouldn’t apply to the insulin/air embolus pairs.
absolutely none to absolutely duck all.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 8
My thoughts are that if she is guilty, she might not have been able to come up with a reason that sounded innocent, that doesn’t raise suspicion, so safer to just say you don’t remember doing it. If she’s guilty then her thoughts aren’t going to be like ours where an innocent explanation is obvious, surely?
God knows. If she can murder all these babies then message her colleagues such blatant lies and pretending to be upset and keep going back into work and repeating it then she must have enough about her to say 'I was concerned for the family'. Of course an evil baby murderer doesn't think the way we do, but she knew enough to speak to her colleagues about it without raising suspicion and she's clearly smart enough to be a qualified and seemingly competent nurse until this point. You'd need some understanding of how normal people would react.

Yeah it’s mad isn’t it. Hmm I don’t think there’s any sign she was distraught in these interviews. I also think if I was distraught I’d still have a better answer and be saying I know it was wrong to look them up but it didn’t mean anything etc. Her answers are very low key imo. I think she knows it’s not a good idea to try and tell detailed lies and that’s just an quick answer. She’s going down the lack of memory route a fair amount.
I know, maybe you're right it just makes no sense at all. I suppose we don't know her emotions in the interviews, they just take a direct transcript of her words rather than comment on her mood but something about some of her answers sounds like she doesn't want to get into more trouble or something? Like she knows it's wrong to search for families so is playing dumb?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
To the point now.

I have a theory that she was targeting families rather than babies themselves. This would explain why she attempted to murder twins and triplets and then obsessed about the parents. So I think it was the parents she wanted to hurt.
Yes this could be a plausible explanation. Or she may have done this to the babies if the families spoke to her in a way she* didn’t like or were rude to her in any way. I’m really interested to see what the prosecution say her motive was. I think we should expect one at some point shouldn’t we? Maybe at the closing statement?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5
I honestly love we are all now Fellas til april, and all take the same view on this one. Anyone who is having a go at someone (not the usual posters, the ott ones that just seem to come on here to attack others) from now on I’m just going to reply to them with “please stop being a not nice fella”🤣🤣🤣
I’ll always be a fella, it’s in my blood now 😉
 
  • Haha
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 9
God knows. If she can murder all these babies then message her colleagues such blatant lies and pretending to be upset and keep going back into work and repeating it then she must have enough about her to say 'I was concerned for the family'. Of course an evil baby murderer doesn't think the way we do, but she knew enough to speak to her colleagues about it without raising suspicion and she's clearly smart enough to be a qualified and seemingly competent nurse until this point. You'd need some understanding of how normal people would react.



I know, maybe you're right it just makes no sense at all. I suppose we don't know her emotions in the interviews, they just take a direct transcript of her words rather than comment on her mood but something about some of her answers sounds like she doesn't want to get into more trouble or something? Like she knows it's wrong to search for families so is playing dumb?
Honestly..none of it adds up. How can she remember the parents full names to search them after months and months (in sets of parents from the case & in quick succession) but can’t remember their grief. If you were looking them up out of concern for how they’re doing, I think it would be because their grief had a lasting impact on you. Looking them up in quick succession and on Christmas Day etc (high chance for memorial posts) just isn’t your typical nosiness/ out of concern for them type search. It is sinister.
Again, the air embolism thing- she 100% knows the answer to that question. Why not answer? If she was truly innocent, surely she’d have no idea of the significance of air embolism yet 🙃
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 17
To the point now.

I have a theory that she was targeting families rather than babies themselves. This would explain why she attempted to murder twins and triplets and then obsessed about the parents. So I think it was the parents she wanted to hurt.
Yeah that makes sense I was thinking why the twins and triplets. But if she chooses victims based on the parents that would explain it. So sad
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 7
I don’t think it’s a question of whether she is guilty, it’s a question of how many deaths she can be found guilty for.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 22
I’ll do my weekly reminder 🤣 that with two sets of twins, it’s alleged one twin had insulin poisoning and the other twin had air emblous. What are the chances of that!



It’s possible she targeted both so it might look like they had the same mystery illness? Although that wouldn’t apply to the insulin/air embolus pairs.
Also with the triplets the one that survived was actually the sicker baby and in a different room. I assume she didn’t have access to that one. What are the chances the healthier ones both die. ☹
 
  • Sad
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 12
Yeah it’s mad isn’t it. Hmm I don’t think there’s any sign she was distraught in these interviews. I also think if I was distraught I’d still have a better answer and be saying I know it was wrong to look them up but it didn’t mean anything etc. Her answers are very low key imo. I think she knows it’s not a good idea to try and tell detailed lies and that’s just an quick answer. She’s going down the lack of memory route a fair amount.
I think if was guilty of something and was confronted my first impulse might be to say ‘I don’t remember’, it’s a quick get out if you’ve not had time to ‘get your story straight’.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10
I think if was guilty of something and was confronted my first impulse might be to say ‘I don’t remember’, it’s a quick get out if you’ve not had time to ‘get your story straight’.
Yes possibly. Just becomes a problem when you’ve then remembered much stranger little details that help you eh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10
Why do I feel like her defence have a mountain to climb? I get their job is to cast doubt, however so far all I've heard is very generic questioning in to the condition of these babies and the fact they were unwell. Well of course they were, they were in that unit for a reason. And I don't know why, but I can't see the defence dropping a bombshell when they focus on their part.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
Yes possibly. Just becomes a problem when you’ve then remembered much stranger little details that help you eh.
Correct.
If her first instinct is to say ‘I can’t remember’ then how believable would it be to subsequently backtrack and say ‘oh, I do remember, I was concerned’.
Seems to me she’s tied herself up in a bit of a knot with that one.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 11
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.