Lucy Letby Case #13

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
I know hindsight is a wonderful thing, but with the baby being stable and doing well, why wasn’t it a bigger issue that she was suddenly collapsing? Surely if you had a baby that you deemed to be stable and well and then all of a sudden they collapse twice, wouldn’t you be really shocked and wondering what was going on?

I know they were limited in what they could do and they probably didn’t suspect anything sinister at the time, but I just don’t know how they just go back to normal and carry on like it didn’t happen.
I agree with you. But as someone who works in healthcare I would also say that you would never, ever suspect a colleague. I work with adults and it's always the case that a patient can suddenly deteriorate without warning. They can be brought in with a something relatively minor and have a cardiac arrest the next day. It's a well known 'phenomenon' on adult wards that a patient can be 'medically fit' for days, and they day they're due to go home they become unwell. Admittedly I'm not talking about ICU/neonates as I've never worked in those areas, but I think the risk of taking a turn for the worse is even more so due to the body being so fragile. I'm guessing the nurses working in those areas are used to it.
It is hard reading about this case, it is incredibly frustrating because the amount of collapses of different babies in such a relatively short period of time is frightening, and definitely out of the ordinary. Something should definitely have been done sooner, they must have known for a while something was going wrong. I can't remember specific names, but the doctor who testified earlier on that he raised concerns and was told to 'be quiet' or words to that effect, is absolutely shocking.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 12
If the other nurse was away for her break then, regardless of who actually signed or done the prescribed interventions, LL would have opportunities to inject air into the port on Baby D’s IV line at anytime.
The fact that the other nurse was on a break would seem like the perfect opportunity to me.
I think it’s also relevant that these attacks happened at night. With less people around.
Thank you Fellow Fella, think that’s the point I was trying to make, but didn’t make it very well. Glad there’s always someone on here that makes more sense than what goes on in my head🤣

I go and do some work for a few hours and miss all the good fella banter!

I do hope we don't trigger another telling off for 'merailing' the thread for the hard-core who want court details. I'm in agreement with @OldBlondie that sometimes we need a bit of light relief especially when things get tense. And it helps to bring together people who have otherwise been at odds with their opinions. Otherwise we'd just be a group of people spending hours talking about dying babies! And that's not to take away the importance of that. I'm sure wherever we are around the fence we're all agreed that these babies and their families deserve to have their stories heard and for lessons to be learned to prevent whatever has happened from happening again.

That said my humour can be dark and inappropriate, so if at any point a line is crossed feel free to give me a virtual slap round the chops with a Chicago Town.
I honestly love we are all now Fellas til april, and all take the same view on this one. Anyone who is having a go at someone (not the usual posters, the ott ones that just seem to come on here to attack others) from now on I’m just going to reply to them with “please stop being a not nice fella”🤣🤣🤣
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 14
I think anyone with medical knowledge, and many without, would find these incidents bizarre and unexplainable. Even the consultant in, was it, Baby C’s case said that he had never seen these symptoms before and admitted that he couldn’t explain them, so much so that he sent the baby’s case to the coroner.
If a Consultant with decades of experience comes to these conclusions, along with many other medicinal professionals, then, what little old me thinks, with my lesser knowledge and experience, is not the mainstay of my reasoning, although it does inform it.
And, yes, I think they’d find her guilty, without doubt.
I felt medical professionals would be more likely to question the testimony. I have absolutely no trouble ignoring medical experts if I feel their testimony isn't representing the facts. I don't necessarily mean this trial but I don't subscribe to the view medical experts are always right.... I'd like to question them myself 😂😂... I also think lots of my on the fenceness comes from such poor reporting of the medical side of things.

I'm still banging the Dunning Kruger drum... Particularly from the nurse with 20 yrs experience who can't interpret an ABG and says the doctors will deal with that. It stinks. It means I struggle to believe the attending doctors because tit standards tend to settle across the board.... Then I struggle with the doctors old boy network thing... They'll all know each other, particularly if any of them are published... They won't know each others' standards or practice because that would be minor compared to the back slapping and self congratulation that goes on.

Sorry for the long rant. A lot of this is just speculation, obviously, much like the dog eating Stardust's Sil. It's just I literally trust no one... And need to turn everything over in my mind.


Not an over thinker much!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5
In that case fella, frigging toast it is 🤣

Edit...ffs I've just actually spotted your avatar and it is literally fried egg on toast. Off to crawl into the stupid corner 🙈🙈🙈
Um I’ve literally never noticed 😱😆 frigging toast have you just added that to clear things up ? Surely that hasn’t been your avatar the whole time ?! I don’t believe it 🤔😆
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 6
Um I’ve literally never noticed 😱😆 frigging toast have you just added that to clear things up ? Surely that hasn’t been your avatar the whole time ?! I don’t believe it 🤔😆
I’m sure it was just an f before. I feel like I’m going mad. I’m calling everyone in the house a fella and you can bet I’m serving ‘frigging toast’ for breakfast.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 8
Um I’ve literally never noticed 😱😆 frigging toast have you just added that to clear things up ? Surely that hasn’t been your avatar the whole time ?! I don’t believe it 🤔😆
I’m sure it was just an f before. I feel like I’m going mad. I’m calling everyone in the house a fella and you can bet I’m serving ‘frigging toast’ for breakfast.
Hahaha omg conspiracy 😭
No I changed my picture today your honour! Not guilty!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 7
I've just finished work, been trying to keep up all day (work from home on Fridays so not too bad)

Sorry if this has been asked or if I've misunderstood something, but should medical staff always write when a note is in retrospect?
Nurse Oakley only says she believes that some 'notes were written in retrospect'. Is this something Ben Myers can dispute when he presents LL defence?
 

Attachments

  • Like
Reactions: 4
It also sounds like the 1:14 hrs ABG should have been actioned, after 3 showing acidosis and this would be caused by repiratory issues, namely too much CO2 on board. I'm so out of date, I've forgotten so much. Have I got that correct, can someone clever please confirm??
I see no actions to improve that , until they crash.
I’m really out of date too.
It seems to me that Baby D should have been taken to SCBU, probably right after birth, especially as it had been a c-section and therefore her lungs may not have been totally clear of amniotic fluid.
I can’t comment too much on the blood gases, but do agree that they indicate there was too much CO2 on board. Where I worked latterly we didn’t use IVs or arterial lines.
We used SpO2 monitors (oxygen saturation), with finger probes.
Baby D’s oxygen saturations were 100%, you can’t get better than that, and that was in air with only, non-invasive, nasal CPAP. That means Baby C was breathing spontaneously with a a tiny bit of pressure to help keep her lungs open. After the first collapse she only needed a bit of oxygen and suction to bring her round.
I acknowledge that her care does not appear to have been optimal but I don’t think she was in imminent danger of dying.
I really want to hear the Dr’s interpretations of the blood gases and acidosis.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 11
I agree with you. But as someone who works in healthcare I would also say that you would never, ever suspect a colleague. I work with adults and it's always the case that a patient can suddenly deteriorate without warning. They can be brought in with a something relatively minor and have a cardiac arrest the next day. It's a well known 'phenomenon' on adult wards that a patient can be 'medically fit' for days, and they day they're due to go home they become unwell. Admittedly I'm not talking about ICU/neonates as I've never worked in those areas, but I think the risk of taking a turn for the worse is even more so due to the body being so fragile. I'm guessing the nurses working in those areas are used to it.
It is hard reading about this case, it is incredibly frustrating because the amount of collapses of different babies in such a relatively short period of time is frightening, and definitely out of the ordinary. Something should definitely have been done sooner, they must have known for a while something was going wrong. I can't remember specific names, but the doctor who testified earlier on that he raised concerns and was told to 'be quiet' or words to that effect, is absolutely shocking.
Yeah I can understand you’d not suspect your colleagues usually, it’s more just that I don’t know how they weren’t more on alert after these collapses happened twice with the baby on the same night.

Usually with neonates they deteriorate before they collapse, it’s unusual for them to just go into cardiac arrest like this. There would usually be signs or illnesses.

Such a sad case and I think so many people would look back and wish things could have been different.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 5
I felt medical professionals would be more likely to question the testimony. I have absolutely no trouble ignoring medical experts if I feel their testimony isn't representing the facts. I don't necessarily mean this trial but I don't subscribe to the view medical experts are always right.... I'd like to question them myself 😂😂... I also think lots of my on the fenceness comes from such poor reporting of the medical side of things.

I'm still banging the Dunning Kruger drum... Particularly from the nurse with 20 yrs experience who can't interpret an ABG and says the doctors will deal with that. It stinks. It means I struggle to believe the attending doctors because tit standards tend to settle across the board.... Then I struggle with the doctors old boy network thing... They'll all know each other, particularly if any of them are published... They won't know each others' standards or practice because that would be minor compared to the back slapping and self congratulation that goes on.

Sorry for the long rant. A lot of this is just speculation, obviously, much like the dog eating Stardust's Sil. It's just I literally trust no one... And need to turn everything over in my mind.


Not an over thinker much!!!
I see where you’re coming from and I too wouldn’t want to swallow Dr’s opinions whole, but there are many, with some from different fields also. Interested to hear what the pathologists have to say.
I think the nurse would very well know how to interpret ABG readings but, in the context of the trail, she would leave the explanation of the ABGs to the Drs as they were the ones who would have to justifying and explain the actions they took. Not her.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 6
Hahaha omg conspiracy 😭
No I changed my picture today your honour! Not guilty!
Whilst we're on the subject of pictures I can't trust that @Milktray Fella cause I swear those are quality street, not milk tray.
Gonna email that Dr fella from court to confirm.

Anyway back to LL. Still in the guilty camp
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 17
Whilst we're on the subject of pictures I can't trust that @Milktray Fella cause I swear those are quality street, not milk tray.
Gonna email that Dr fella from court to confirm.

Anyway back to LL. Still in the guilty camp
Noooo! I was hoping you fellas wouldn't notice!
I like playing about with different chocolate...Sshhh don't tell anyone!

And yeah, still guilty!
 
  • Haha
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 10
This is a bit of a weird one but if I was in court, up against these charges, having to listen to all these accounts of these poor babies passing & I was innocent, I’d be absolutely sobbing. I wouldn’t be able to control it but I’m wondering if that would be viewed as guilt?
I’d be the same sobbing my heart out, I would have contempt of court Conviction added on to my own case as I wouldn’t be able to keep my mouth shut knowing I was innocent and having to listen to the prosecutions case against me. My friends and family have always said my mouth would/will get me into trouble 😂 but I’m not going sugar coat tit like Willy Wonka just to please others
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 6
I’m really out of date too.
It seems to me that Baby D should have been taken to SCBU, probably right after birth, especially as it had been a c-section and therefore her lungs may not have been totally clear of amniotic fluid.
I can’t comment too much on the blood gases, but do agree that they indicate there was too much CO2 on board. Where I worked latterly we didn’t use IVs or arterial lines.
We used SpO2 monitors (oxygen saturation), with finger probes.
Baby D’s oxygen saturations were 100%, you can’t get better than that, and that was in air with only, non-invasive, nasal CPAP. That means Baby C was breathing spontaneously with a a tiny bit of pressure to help keep her lungs open. After the first collapse she only needed a bit of oxygen and suction to bring her round.
I acknowledge that her care does not appear to have been optimal but I don’t think she was in imminent danger of dying.
I really want to hear the Dr’s interpretations of the blood gases and acidosis.
Me too. It's interesting. I'm not sure capillary O2 sats mean all that much when the ABGs are off. I might also be reeling in 30 yr shock from when I ducked up someones ABGs.. It was impressed on me this IS one of the indicators of acute decline.

Let's hope for better reporting.

I still work in health, this is improving my practice and my business, not least because I'm going to review that all my paperwork is solid and though I don't work in acute health I'm going to really make sure my clients are getting the best.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 9
That's the issue, and that's why the ambulance turns up. She'll know key words that'll get them moving, but can you imagine if they ignored it one day and she was found days later having been eaten by the dog or something.
Or if the dog phoned for an ambulance feeling poorly because it had eaten her! 😱🤪
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 4
Are you actually for real? Not everyone is a native speaker, LDs exist and not everyone has had access to a good education. What a petty thing to come on here and cry about.
If this is genuinely causing you to become ‘frazzled’ then you need help.
I’m not a native speaker and still find this error really annoying 🤣🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I've just finished work, been trying to keep up all day (work from home on Fridays so not too bad)

Sorry if this has been asked or if I've misunderstood something, but should medical staff always write when a note is in retrospect?
Nurse Oakley only says she believes that some 'notes were written in retrospect'. Is this something Ben Myers can dispute when he presents LL defence?
It really depends. If I was documenting at 1.45 something that happened at 1.15 then I wouldn't clarify that it was in retrospect because most care is documented a bit late, you can't do an intervention and write about it at the exact same time. However in this case where she was on her break and not present during the notes I would be clarifying that it was written in retrospect and on behalf of another nurse, she's putting her name to something she has no idea whether it's happened or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.