I was reading comments on reddit over the last couple of days and thought some of them were pretty harsh. I was still hopeful, but I'm looking through the Rouge portal now and, honestly, I'm really underwhelmed and uninspired.
4 out of 8 shades (Romy/Ashes/Lisa/Medici) are some variation of Muse, which itself isn't the universally flattering shade Lisa seems to think it is.
Then we have Ribbon ... in yet another formula ... for double the price of the other Ribbons.
Boho Cherry is a special occasion colour, which begs the question when will you even need a refill, 3 years from now? and why buy a £50 lipstick you only bring out at Christmas? It does look stunning on the deepest-skin model though, but it's not going to suit me. I have Myth and Jazz which I rarely (never) wear.
Audrey is nice, but I already recreate that look with MAC Boldly Bare + Baume Meet Cute.
Simone is also nice but I can recreate it with MAC Stripdown and any clear lip balm.
The case has no appeal for me.
Sorry, this is a miss.
I did get the cleanser autumn set, & looking forward to using it. Hopefully it works for me this time.