Gender Discussion #105

[YeahBrackie]

No idea why a care home in Oxford is showing up on My Facebook news feed, but ffs How kind that they've given him his very own photoshoot (would they have done that for anyone else?) in which he can flaunt his fetish which he'll also now be flaunting around vulnerable care home residents

 

[MaineCoonMama]

My late mother had dementia, it felt terrible when she was confused about me being an adult when she thought I was still a child.
How could a person purposely do that to their unwell parent?

 

[Moon Face]

The parents of a six-year-old trans girl who tried to cut off her penis with plastic scissors after being told she couldn’t join Rainbows, the youngest Girlguiding group, have called the decision to ban trans girls “incredibly upsetting”. (The Observer)

Girlguiding facing mass exodus after setting deadline for...

archived 29 Mar 2026 10:22:44 UTC

archive.ph

Whilst it is possible to have every sympathy for the 6 year child, they should never have been put into this position. The parents are solely to blame for what this poor child is going through.

The child also needs some serious mental health intervention. Trying to cut of your penis is not normal behaviour and it really isn't because "if I didn't have a penis I could go to Rainbows"

 

[FourSeasonSoupObsessive]

That’s fucking sick.

How about we re write that from his mother‘s point of view? Once a week she sees someone who looks like her son, telling her he’s her daughter. Her poor brain struggles to make sense of this information, and given a lifetime of female socialisation, she knows that contradicting delusional men carries a penalty, so she goes along with it. What must she make of it? What is she thinking?

He doesn’t even MENTION her feelings. Just let her have her remaining memories of her son, you self centred abusive prick. Fuck me, that’s got me raging. These men NEVER think of anyone but their sad delusional selves.

 

[Funny_bunny]

The ever brilliant JKR.

 

[moldwarp]

I hate the way these headlines are written as poor little “trans girls” evicted from an activity they enjoy. It should instead be “Girl Guiding forced to adhere to the law and address their lax safeguarding”.

I think just "Boys must leave Girl Guides" would be an accurate headline. Since a) 'transgender girls' are boys and b) there's no such thing as a trans child, just abusive / narc parents, or a child with undiagnosed or untreated mental illness or neurodivergence.

I mean, I know the BBC isn't exactly known for its accuracy, impartiality or high reporting standards, but this blatant propagandising should really have been left behind in 2020. The Overton Window's shifted, Mr BBC. The great unwashed, the hoi polloi whom you despise so much, aren't buying this shit anymore, if they ever did. Which is doubtful.

 

[Weebles Wobble]

I hate the way troons seem to think anyone supporting women having privacy is taking away their rights.

 

[TheMiceInTheShed]

Oh fuck off you pathetic hand maiden. How can you not see that allowing anyone to pretend to be a woman and we should all blindly accept it is damaging for women’s rights. They keep banging on about how terrible it is to reduce being a woman to biology, but surely that’s exactly what it is. It’s not a feeling, it’s not wanting to dress a certain way and it’s certainly not celebrating and accepting male sexual fetishes being inflicted on us without consent. Do these stupid handmaidens have any idea how much many TIM hate us? That they have the male mindset, male physical strength and retain their male anatomy? However much they may dress up in a grotesque parody of being a woman, they retain their male physical strength and mindset. Whatever they claim to “identify” as they have all the characteristics of MEN.

Tell me, Nadia - who is "narrowing the definition of womanhood"?

The definition of womanhood is, and always has been, "adult human female". No-one is narrowing it.

You are fighting to forcibly widen it to include men.

Being female is TOTALLY dependent upon BIOLOGY. It has nothing to do with what you wear, how long your hair is, or how you "feel" inside (how the hell does a man know how being a woman "feels"? - nobody knows how anyone else feels). A man can dress like a 50p trollop if he likes, but shouldn't expect the rest of us to validate his "gender expression". He looks like what they are - a perverted man.

The tiny proportion who have a genuine body dysphoria (which is a mental illness) are the ones who will ultimately suffer the most, and I pity them - but not as much as I pity women and girls who aren't allowed to have a single space, award or opportunity for themselves. because trans-identifying men are not only given access to their spaces, but are given priority - how else can we explain so many of them being offered top jobs in areas which are actually women's expertise? What does a man know about the experience of endometriosis, for instance? Nothing - and he never can.

We are women because every chromosome in our body screams XX - even in the bodies of masculine women. WE ARE WOMEN ENTIRELY BECAUSE OF OUR BIOLOGY AND YOU KNOW IT.

 

[DoraMaar]

 

[IngressUK]

The Hannah Spencer incident in Manchester.

What really, really, REALLY irrates me about this is the typical one sided attitude once again on display.

If this was a public gathering featuring KJK, Helen Joyce, or May Forstater, then the Pro Trans brigade would have no issues with disrupting their speech, and harassing and shouting abuse at them in public.

Yet when it comes to a Pro Trans individual, they do not like it one bit.

Laying hands on counter protestors, invading their personal spaces, and thinking these individuals do not have a right to their opinion.

They also don't like when their Pro trans ally is getting abuse, abuse that they are more than happy to dish out to someone who is 'TERF'.

I also find it laughable that 'defund and abolish the Police' Hannah Spencer, soon changes her tune when she needs them for protection.

Still want to defund the Police, Hannah?

Utter bloody hypocrite!

The moral to all this.

If these idiots think it is fair game to shut down opposing opinions, then they have no right to object when others try to do the same regarding their opinions.

It is very much they expect to be unchallenged when airing their views - but don't offer that to anyone else.

 

[DoraMaar]

"That's £15.50 in Good Law's coffers".

This is Zach Polanski's post of Wembley last night - I love JH's comment re ZPs previous occupation

 

[threeSMEGfridges]

I hate the way these headlines are written as poor little “trans girls” evicted from an activity they enjoy. It should instead be “Girl Guiding forced to adhere to the law and address their lax safeguarding”.

Im tired that it's assumed all leaders are "so sad and disappointed" that we've "got no option"

some of us are just relived that we don't have to wait on instructions on this anymore and a decision has been made. And we don't have to privately hope we'll not be asked to take a trans girl on camp; or go on a leaders training weekend and find we're in a dormitory with other leaders one of whom is a Laydeee like Monica Sulley

 

[Funny_bunny]

Oh fuck off you pathetic hand maiden. How can you not see that allowing anyone to pretend to be a woman and we should all blindly accept it is damaging for women’s rights. They keep banging on about how terrible it is to reduce being a woman to biology, but surely that’s exactly what it is. It’s not a feeling, it’s not wanting to dress a certain way and it’s certainly not celebrating and accepting male sexual fetishes being inflicted on us without consent. Do these stupid handmaidens have any idea how much many TIM hate us? That they have the male mindset, male physical strength and retain their male anatomy? However much they may dress up in a grotesque parody of being a woman, they retain their male physical strength and mindset. Whatever they claim to “identify” as they have all the characteristics of MEN.

 

[Phil Anne Throw Pee]

Jonathan Willoughby is an evil, mentally deranged piece of shit. He fathered a son with his sperm and yet claims to be a biological woman. You couldn't make this shit up.

 

[Funny_bunny]

That was revolting. I’ve never felt that TWAW, and I’m afraid that men dressing up as women is something I’ve always found creepy as hell. However, I’m at the point now where I think the vast majority of TIM are sick perverts who take great delight in making women uncomfortable and bullying them into accepting them with all this “bigot” and “ transphobe” nonsense, while they force their sexual fetishes on others without consent. I’m sure that’s all part of the thrill. I’ve gone from finding them creepy and weird to thinking they’re vile, dangerous perverts. I’d also argue that I’m not a “transphobe”. I’m sure that a phobia is an irrational dislike or fear and I’d say there is nothing irrational about wanting to avoid these perverted vile creeps like the plague.

 

[emmer_moans]

They can't go camping with Girl Guides and now they're not free to batter female athletes and potentially give them brain damage. It's been a bad week for the troons.

and JK Rowling is still living her best life raking in the coin depsite the TRAs' best efforts.

 

[Funny_bunny]

Another porn addled pervert. Looks like a creep and thinks like a creep. The more of this vile stuff they come out with, the more I detest them.

Edit to add a picture of the gorgeous, feminine Kirsti . Think Krusti would be more apt.

 

[petitspois]

I just can’t think of any other law - actual law- that is discussed, obfuscated, downplayed and outright ignored than this. It was a fucking clarification too, not an actual change in law!

 

[FourSeasonSoupObsessive]

Jenni Murray has died

She was an absolute icon. I will never forgive Woman’s Hour for phasing her out for gently supposing that men can’t actually be women. She was so sensible, so reasonable, so balanced (and so RIGHT). They really don’t make them like that any more.

Dame Jenni Murray: Former BBC Woman's Hour host dies at 75

She was the Radio 4 programme's longest-serving presenter, having left in 2020 after 33 years.

www.bbc.co.uk

 

[Healthymama]

I'm getting so sick of all this shit. For the most oppressed section of society they sure as hell get a lot of air time. They just can't leave anything alone.

Elizabeth I had to really be a man, not just a sassy bad ass woman. It's all back to stereotypes, any woman who dared to act outside the oppressed, submissive woman was obviously trans.

The ridiculous thing with this “reimagining” nonsense is that if Elizabeth had been a man then everyone would have been blooming delighted! Henry needed a male heir, hence the divorces, beheadings and all round lunacy of his reign. If E1 had been a boy, Anne would never have been beheaded, there would be no six wives stuff, Edward would never have been born and the realm would have been secure from the threats from France and Spain. Everyone wanted a boy, there would have been rejoicing in the streets. Honestly, whoever came up with this is an utter moron with no idea about history, even as a piece if fiction it doesn’t hold up. How has it been given the go ahead in the first place? It’s utter dross. I despair.
The TRA’s need to leave historical figures alone. E1 was a woman who defied cultural norms, as was Joan of Arc, who they’ve had a crack at transing as well. Who next, Emmaline Pankhurst, secretly a man campaigning for votes for women? Nothing would surprise me. What a bunch of bellends.