I’ve been thinking about this quite a bit this evening. If a 5* event rider posted videos of a horse regularly refusing jumps and being kicked, whipped and shouted at as a result, you can guarantee that there would be uproar, and rightly so. If this rider then turned around and said “yes but the horse is capable of jumping that height”, you certainly wouldn’t think much of them.
Oliver Townend got crucified for flogging a tired horse at Badminton and I’m fairly sure nobody would have said that it was ok for him to do that because the horse was treated well at home and was regularly spoilt with treats etc.
Not even thinking about WW now, but as a general thing, why should we stop advocating for the welfare of horses? If it would be frowned upon at the top level, why should we shut up and put up at the lower levels? Of course, you can’t police the actions of everyone at every yard in the land, but if someone is going to post it publicly, made into a vlog-style film to be easily watched by followers, why shouldn’t people be able to speak up and say they dislike the way an animal is being treated?
Mark Todd was absolutely torn to shreds for hitting a horses bum with a branch. Would it have been any different if he’d been booting it in the ribs and screaming? What’s worse on the scale of what’s acceptable and who makes that call?
Im all for warts and all vlogs, but I dislike it when a riders temper or desire to achieve something comes before the welfare of the animal. This evening, a friend actually pointed me in the direction of a recent Harlow vlog, who I don’t generally watch. Harlow’s pony refused a jump twice in the SJ phase of an event. She quietly tried again and he went over third time. He later refused another fence and again, she quietly popped him back over it. No drama and no fuss and she then came on camera to say she had been eliminated due to 3 refusals and was unable to go on to the XC phase. She never once blamed that pony, or lost her rag with him. She simply represented him without fuss. And she is 11 years old.
Horses have no voice, and they actually do an awful lot for us that we have no right to ask of them. As a result, we can, and regularly do, abuse that power. We absolutely should be held accountable for our actions and I believe that people should speak out if they see something that makes them uncomfortable with regards the treatment of any animal. The fragility of a humans mental health should not trump the welfare of the horse.