Lucy Letby Case #2

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Definitely major red flags if someone is hiding a relationship from their social worker and they have at risk kids. The mothers of Baby P and Arthur Labinjo-Hughes both did this IIRC. They hid the relationships because their kids were already At Risk and both men had previous form for abuse. So, yeah, I think it would be quite smart of a diligent SW to check that on SM.
Arthur's mother was in jail on a manslaughter charge and his father was open about being with Emma Tustin. Imagine trying to build trust with parents and then snooping behind their backs. It's giving snide and sly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
I’m following this trial closely, very interested in it. I don’t know too much about NICU but I worked in a geriatric ward (old people). We had a lot of staffing problems there, not just lack of staff but a lot of very lazy staff who just tended to do as little work as possible. They tried to install cameras but the back lash from the staff (ironically the ones who didn’t do any work) was crazy. We dealt with a lot of dementia patients who would wonder around, sometimes with no clothes on, and the staff were in uproar about this being on camera to the point where they retracted their decision and only had cameras on the exit/entrance rather than actually in the ward.

One girl was particularly passionate about the cameras not going ahead, talking about how she’d feel if her nan was on camera in a ward. She felt so strongly that she handed her notice in over this. Interestingly, a week after handing her notice in in protest, she was sacked as she was witnessed hitting a patient…. I was so surprised and this seemed so out of character from what I knew of her and how she’d acted working alongside me. You never know what goes on behind closed doors…

As for the Facebook things, I’m the worst at this. I’m a big Facebook stalker and will admit I’ve looked at families of people I’ve cared for. Nothing sinister, just really nosey. I know this will be frowned upon and people think I should get a life.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Angry
Reactions: 23
Did anyone else watch a Panorama documentary around the beginning of this Year regarding Catastrophic failures at an NHS trust (Shropshire Telford) may have led to the deaths of more than 200 babies, nine mothers and left other infants with life-changing injuries, it was so upsetting to see many parents raised concerns over the trust and were fobbed off
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Wow
Reactions: 13
I know it’s not illegal but I would be so creeped out if I found out the midwives that delivered my babies were creeping on my social media accounts after I had given birth. The woman is clearly unhinged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 19
There probably are other suspected victims which they couldn't bring in this round of charges cos lack of evidence but they'll no doubt try to bring them in future.
They have just done the same with David Fuller, 16 extra charges. Must have involved exhumations with his necrophilia not being discovered. He had a room full of terabytes of wierd stuff.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
  • Sad
Reactions: 6
Arthur's mother was in jail on a manslaughter charge and his father was open about being with Emma Tustin. Imagine trying to build trust with parents and then snooping behind their backs. It's giving snide and sly.
Yes, you're right. It was Logan Mwangi I was thinking of, not Arthur. Thank you. I also believe Star Hobson's mother initially hid her new relationship from her social worker.

On topic - the opening statement by the prosecutor did rely very heavily on circumstantial evidence. I think that's why it took the polict three goes and a couple of years before they had enough evidence to charge her. Being on the ward at the times of the collapses is highly suggestive and I've no doubt that other ward staff noticed it. But that's very different from having concrete evidence that the accused actually did it.

A third option this thread should therefore consider is that she DID do it but gets off because the evidence remains too circumstantial for the jury to convict. What would be called 'Not Proven' in Scottish Law, but England & Wales doesn't have that option.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 11
Oh god sky news have accidentally named child c by not redacting a quote. I hope they realise and remove it
The children have all been named before, in older news articles. Is there a reason they are not being named in reporting now? I’m assuming it’s to protect the identity of the parents/prevent them from being hounded online? And also any surviving siblings I suppose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Baby Ds case seems particularly sad as she was full term and first failed by the hospital itself with mum not being given antibiotics when she should have been. 😔
 
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: 17
Yes, you're right. It was Logan Mwangi I was thinking of, not Arthur. Thank you. I also believe Star Hobson's mother initially hid her new relationship from her social worker.

On topic - the opening statement by the prosecutor did rely very heavily on circumstantial evidence. I think that's why it took the polict three goes and a couple of years before they had enough evidence to charge her. Being on the ward at the times of the collapses is highly suggestive and I've no doubt that other ward staff noticed it. But that's very different from having concrete evidence that the accused actually did it.

A third option this thread should therefore consider is that she DID do it but gets off because the evidence remains too circumstantial for the jury to convict. What would be called 'Not Proven' in Scottish Law, but England & Wales doesn't have that option.
Honestly not trying to pick at you but Savannah was openly present and spoke to social workers herself. But as you were saying I just haven't seen anything so far that makes me think 'yep she did it'. Looking people up on fb as bad as it is and being around more deaths then usual on a NICU unit just isn't cutting it for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4
Baby Ds case seems particularly sad as she was full term and first failed by the hospital itself with mum not being given antibiotics when she should have been. 😔
Reading about this case has really upset me, my daughter was born at full term with an infection but I knew I had GBS that could cause it and so had tested before the birth to ensure I had the antibiotics when my waters went. She still got an infection and spent some time at the nicu for antibiotics via cannula in the countess in April 2016 and I dread to think if she had been more poorly because I hadn’t had the antibiotics and she had needed to stay over night what might have happened 😓 That poor poor baby. My heart aches
 
  • Sad
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 10
Honestly not trying to pick at you but Savannah was openly present and spoke to social workers herself. But as you were saying I just haven't seen anything so far that makes me think 'yep she did it'. Looking people up on fb as bad as it is and being around more deaths then usual on a NICU unit just isn't cutting it for me.
Sure, the social workers were aware of Brockhill's presence in the months before Star's death but initially Smith sought to hide the relationship from her family and from social services - it was only after Hollie Jones made the initial referral in Jan 2020 and then Anita Smith followed up five times that SWs seriously started to engage with them as a couple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
Can you direct me to the specific legislation that says that someone looking at another’s public signal media profile is a breach of GDPR? I can’t see it anywhere?
Not just anyone. A professional. It's about application of the law. As a professional uou can't use another person's personal information in any way other than the ways you've told them or as outlined in the organisation's privacy policy, it's down to the organisation whether or not they include social media as part of that.

I feel this is dragging on now. The original point I had attempted to make in relation to the case is that it was in no way ok for LL to be searching for families she met in a professional capacity, innocently or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12
Sure, the social workers were aware of Brockhill's presence in the months before Star's death but initially Smith sought to hide the relationship from her family and from social services - it was only after Hollie Jones made the initial referral in Jan 2020 and then Anita Smith followed up five times that SWs seriously started to engage with them as a couple.
Oh I didn't know that. Well we've both learnt from each other today lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1
This is heartbreaking


12:22pm

Letby said the registrar would be down to review Child E, and urged her to return to the postnatal ward.
The mum called her husband when she got to the labour ward, in a call lasting four minutes and 25 seconds, at 9.11pm.
Letby made a note in Child F's records (Child F being the twin of Child E), "after she had got rid of" the mum, Mr Johnson said.
The next time the mum visited Child E, he was in terminal decline.

12:21pm

Child E was 'acutely distressed' and bleeding from the mouth.
The mum said Letby attempted to reassure her the blood was due to the NGT ittirating the throat.
"Trust me, I'm a nurse," Mr Johnson told the court.

12:20pm

At 9pm on August 3, 2015, the mother decided to visit her twin sons, and "interrupted Lucy Letby who was in the process of attacking Child E", the prosecution say, although the mum "did not realise it at the time".
 
  • Sad
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 29
I think the evidence of the forensic pathologist(s) will be key in this case. Can they prove the babies were deliberately injured? If deliberate injury wasn’t initially suspected the PMs might not have been so thorough as a Home Office PM. If the PMs did pick up deliberate injury from the outset then surely they would’ve shut the unit to investigate & prevent further deaths? Which makes me think the initial PMs didn’t pick up on deliberate injury & this is going to be a contentious area.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.