Hi

new to this thread.
I started following Jess maybe a couple of years ago. I admired the way she was making a name for herself as a working class woman in academia and I thought some of what she said, her tiktoks about victim blaming etc. were interesting and accessible.
I also felt a connection to some of her anti-psychiatry rhetoric because I have a diagnosed mental illness that I choose to manage without medication. (I feel I should be clear, this is my decision about my health, on the basis of medication effectiveness vs side effects, and while I've often doubted my own diagnosis I'm not someone who believes that mental illnesses don't exist, or that medication is never the answer for anyone.)
She posted her suicide post on LinkedIn, and that's where I saw it, and it shocked me.
The times in my life when I've been most suicidal and most in danger of doing myself serious harm are the times when I've had the least insight, when I've genuinely believed that I was well and rational and the urge to die was a logical consequence of the way life made me feel, and that anyone else's concern or wish for me not to commit suicide came from their selfishness or sentimentality.
Insight saved my life. The acknowledgement that feeling a certain way wouldn't last forever, that moods are like weather and I just need to find ways to manage them... that's what helped me move past some really serious crises.
I understand, and to some extent agree with, the argument that trauma is a cause of or contributing factor for many mental illnesses, and that understanding and working through that trauma can be vital to managing and maybe even recovering from a mental illness. I also fully appreciate that some diagnoses come with serious stigma and that stigma is often hugely damaging in very real ways.
But Jess seems to be arguing that the illnesses themselves don't exist, and that all there is is trauma and its logical consequences.
It feels like saying, "don't be ridiculous, you haven't broken your leg - no need for cast, or surgery, or painkillers - you can't walk because that car ran you over. We can fix your problems by talking about the experience of being run over, and prosecuting the driver, and campaigning for safer road policies". All those things may well be helpful and worthwhile things to do, but they're not going to mend that leg.