Notice
Thread ordered by most liked posts - View normal thread.

Sybil

Chatty Member
Decided to watch the first couple of minutes yesterday but to see if it looked like something I’d be interested in watching during lockdown. 4 hours later I’d Finished watching it. I thought it was rally interesting and brilliantly done. I really really hope there will be a second season so we can see how Esty deals with her new life long term.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10

Plainwhited

Active member
I didn't think it was great at all! I was interested in their lifestyle but I found it hard to believe the students would have accepted her so easily. And then it just ended! Very strange
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5

Curlywurly85

Active member
Im absolutely hooked, I knew it was bad but never that bad. I’ve brought the book it was based on and can’t wait to read it. The Netflix documentary One of us is also worth a watch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4

Dizzy

VIP Member
So disappointed with the ending! I wonder if there’ll be a second series 🤔 I’ll try One of Us next as I found it so interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4

Sybil

Chatty Member
Me too!

I really enjoyed it and spent a while reading up on the culture after. The 20 minute behind the scenes episode was interesting too.

There's another documentary on Netflix called 'One of Us' about Hasidic Jews that I'll be watching next.
I’ve put this in my to watch list!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3

Belulah

VIP Member
I found the ending quite bitter sweet. She had her freedom but that would soon evaporate once the baby arrives. I found the name Yanky quite distracting but I guess it suited his character.
I adored the student characters, found them all so watchable and interesting. Would watch a show all about them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
In a newly published interview the actor who played Yanky says they would all love to make another series.

I think it needs one as obviously they will want the child like they did with her mother (and the real life story it is based on).
Yes I think it needs another series. It wasn't fair leaving the viewer hanging like that!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
I was really disappointed with how it ended. I usually avoid watching these things as they are usually created/directed by people who have no inside knowledge and cling to stereotypes. I don't want to post any spoilers but there has been quite a lot of criticism from ex-Satmar jews who said it was very unrealistic and othering. I thought the way she rocked up in Berlin and suddenly became best friends with everyone and was so widely accepted to be very far fetched.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3

Escx

Member
Decided to watch the first couple of minutes yesterday but to see if it looked like something I’d be interested in watching during lockdown. 4 hours later I’d Finished watching it. I thought it was rally interesting and brilliantly done. I really really hope there will be a second season so we can see how Esty deals with her new life long term.
I liked it! It was defiantly interesting learning of another culture which doesn’t get spoken about! I’ve always seen them in airports and Im so intreaged but that series has taught me now 😂 it’s very Amish?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2

navybluewolf

Chatty Member
I watched the first half of the first series but found after a couple of episodes it just wasn’t grabbing my attention. Is it worth holding on and watching all the way through??
It does start slowly but it gets quite dramatic as it goes on. Stuff happens lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2

neo_wales

Well-known member
The show is based on the authors experiences and she's still only 33 years old so maybe leave it another decade then follow on.

The Hasidic sect/branch are still new on the block in biblical terms. I'm Jewish and the Hasidic bunch ain't good at social mingling if your not in their club.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2

Suzesnooze

VIP Member
No apparently there are no plans for another series.
In a newly published interview the actor who played Yanky says they would all love to make another series.

I think it needs one as obviously they will want the child like they did with her mother (and the real life story it is based on).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2

Dizzy

VIP Member
Came in to see if anyone was watching this. I watched 2 episodes last night and will watch the rest this evening. So interesting, so weird. Is it true to life? Kinda blew my mind!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1

Ellabella

VIP Member
Yes, it was very good. How those ultra orthodox religions treat women is hideous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1

Lumpfish

VIP Member
Came in to see if anyone was watching this. I watched 2 episodes last night and will watch the rest this evening. So interesting, so weird. Is it true to life? Kinda blew my mind!
Yes it’s based on a book written by real life Etsy but I haven’t read it so can’t compare!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1